When Katie's parents suggest that Jacob Glick should come for dinner all she can see is a future of darkness. The man is mean to his horses and Katie's life is all about horses. She rescues them and nurses them back to health before selling them on to her Amish friends. Then there is the secret, something happened between them long ago, something she was forced to keep quiet.

Confused and lonely she runs to her lifelong friend Eli Miller. She asks for help, maybe he knows someone that she could court? Only then, does she realize that it is Eli she wanted all along. Of course, Eli has problems of his own. He needs to discover what he should do in life before he can commit to a wife.

For the sake of her family, will Katie marry the man of their choice or will she find her true love?