Return to Puzzle Land is a sequel to the Magic Puzzle. The evil wizard Professor Robinson has put a spell on select puzzles, for the purpose of kidnapping children and making them serve him. When Carmella, Elita, Andy, and Aaron attempt to put a puzzle together, they are zapped into a new world called Puzzle Land. Here, Professor Robinson transforms them into creatures with special abilities. After escaping Puzzle Land, the four children attempt to put their whole scary adventure behind them, but their time in Puzzle Land is not over yet! Aaron is having dreams that the mermaids who helped save them are in trouble. Elita knows they must rescue the other children who were left in Puzzle Land! Nightmares of Professor Robinson still torment them. Will they dare to enter Puzzle Land a second time and rescue the lost children? Will they be able to overcome the tempting choices they must make to put an end to this villain once and for all? Find out as you dare to join our hero's as they return to Puzzle Land!